Midwesterners in Wisconsin and Illinois use pronunciations and phrases that sound comical to west Texans, and vice versa. Their favorite argument revolves around bilingual education. This might even override considerations of race, as the black cultural theorist Frantz Fanon noted in his book Peau noire, masques blancspublished as Black Skin, White Masks in They further argued that, since Ebonics was structured and spoken like any other language, its place in school texts was no more or less arbitrary than Standard English or Spanish.
Despite what the advocates of English as the official language would like people to think, English is not at all on the decline. Official English also cannot help further segregating U.
Should those who come to US shores assimilate to US culture, or maintain their distinctive cultural markers? The troublesome example of official French policy in Quebec offers a cautionary tale One promising avenue for integrating non-speakers comes in the form of bilingual immersion education.
I have lived this issue, and it is incomprehensible to me that anyone would oppose legislation which codifies the language policy for this country. Language is an organic force, and difficult to control. Official English supporters also complain that the United States will have to spend billions of dollars translating federal documents into every imaginable language.
Until English-only advantages can be proven to outweigh the disadvantages, America has no need for an official language. In fact, many argue that the mix of cultures is what makes America America.
Here as elsewhere, people who are isolated by language tend — much like poor people, or victims of sexual assault, for example — to get blamed for their condition. Ebonics was deeply entangled with white perceptions of black otherness, relating to race, class, morality and violence, thus draping it with an added layer of threat.
Immigrants cannot learn English overnight. This is Alabama, they might say, we speak English.
This argument in itself is unsound. Critics of the plan argued that Ebonics was nothing more than substandard English. Eric Miller is assistant professor in communication studies at Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania. Additionally, bilingual education has been proven to be effective.
The Supreme Court, however, has yet to rule on the issue. If English was made to be the official language, immigrants would be required to attend many weeks of ESL English as a Second Language classes. Fidelity to a migrant past is not inherently threatening to a national future. The language gaps between the once-colonies have slowly been filling over time to create an acting international language.
He is a regular contributor at the Religion Dispatches blog. Being able to communicate in English with police officers, for instance, has not kept young black males from filling the rosters of the US penal complex.
The English spoken in Georgia, for instance, is very different from that spoken in Massachusetts. Acceptance into American culture is on the line as well, as people cannot unite socially until they understand each other.
Clearly if English is required to function in society there is a reason to learn English. Performed with ease or clumsiness, awareness or not, guile or good faith, it is none the less something that must be enacted and portrayed, something that must be realized.
Often called the Great Melting Pot, the U. While it is required to have a basic understanding of English before naturalization, many legal citizens have minimal or no English knowledge at all. If imposition is to be avoided as a rule, then federal speech codes must surely qualify.
Supporting migrants and their children to maintain their mother tongue is, he suggested, a racist policy, as it presumes that certain immigrants are incapable of learning English. Speaking English, they might argue, does not guarantee humanity in the eyes of individuals or — perhaps more importantly — systems.
The troublesome example of official French policy in Quebec offers a cautionary tale.Dec 31, · Why English should be the official language of the United States. English is not our official language now, and that means government has to provide services in dozens of languages to.
Why do people come to the United States of America? I believe it because this country has a lot to offer. One of those things is the freedom of speech.
That is why English should not be made the official language in this country. People from all over the world come to enjoy this country's social.
Free Essay: Should English be the Official Language of the United States Name ENG Instructor April 30, Should English be the Official Language of. English is an official language of at least 50 countries.
In this list the United States of America is excluded. English Not The Official Language Of Usa English Language Essay. Print Reference this. Published: 23rd March, Disclaimer: This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our.
A push for English to be the official language of the US has both a dark history and a regressive vision for the future Why would the USA make English an official language? | Aeon Essays We’re turning 6! English should definitely NOT be the official language of the United States. Having multiple languages are what makes America a great country.
Besides, even if we do make it the official language, other people will still speak their native language at home, and there is nothing we can do to stop them.Download